The New York Giants Pass Rush Will Doom their Defense

The New York Giants are one of the heritage franchises of the NFL. Big Blue built their championship legacy on defense. Players like Leonard Marshall, Carl Banks, Osi Umenyiora, Michael Strahan, and Hall of Famer Lawrence Taylor destroyed offensive lines. But with training camp underway, the Giants currently lack a dominant pass rusher. Defensive coordinator James Bettcher hopes outside linebacker Lorenzo Carter, a second-year player drafted in the third round, will become a force on the defensive line. And Carter must produce, because general manager Dave Gettleman waited again until the third round to draft a new pass rusher. Old Dominion’s Oshane Ximines will battle linebackers Markus Golden and Kareem Martin for snaps. Giants fans, the media, and observers are skeptical this defense can disrupt opposing offenses. That’s why the New York Giants lack of a pass rush will doom their defense all season long.

New York Giants Pass Rush Problem

The Giants finished the 2018 regular season with a total of just 30 sacks. The only other team in the NFL with fewer sacks was the Oakland Raiders, who traded linebacker Khalil Mack before the start of the 2018 season. The Giants leading sacker was defensive end Olivier Vernon (seven), who battled injuries and was eventually traded to the Cleveland Browns this off-season. Aside from the actual sacks, the Giants didn’t pressure opposing quarterbacks either. Ryan Dunleavy of broke down the defense’s lack of a pass rush in November 2018. He wrote, “Whether you sack the quarterback or not,” Giants coach Pat Shurmur said…, “pressure is what you’re trying to get.” But, according to Pro Football Focus, through nine games, the Giants had:

  • 119 total pressures, which ranked 31st in the NFL
  • 81 quarterback hurries, which ranked tied for 28th in the NFL
  • 28 quarterback hits, which ranked tied for 20th in the NFL

The pass rush did not improve over the second half of the season. The Giants fired Steve Spagnuolo as defensive coordinator in 2018. New defensive coordinator James Bettcher was considered one of the most aggressive young coaches in the league when hired. And he loves to blitz. The Arizona Cardinals, under Bettcher, were tied for fifth in the NFL in blitz percentage in 2017. The Giants only blitzed 18.4 percent of the time, per PFF.

No Real Improvement

Ralph Vacchiano, NFL and Giants insider who’s currently with SNY, also warns the New York Giants pass rush will doom the defense. He predicts the Giants will not have a player top the team-leading seven sacks from a year ago. Vacchiano wrote on Yahoo! Sports, “the Giants didn’t take any obvious steps to improve their putrid pass rush from a year ago.”

“They think it’s better, but they’re basing that on the hope that Carter (four sacks) can take a big, second-year leap, that free agent linebacker Markus Golden can rediscover his pre-ACL tear form, and that with the inside presence of massive rookie Dexter Lawrence, maybe B.J. Hill (5.5 sacks) can be more dangerous.”

Who’s Available?

The New York Giants, under GM Dave Gettleman, have shown a reluctance to sign top-tier free agents. But Big Blue should not wait to fill their glaring need on their defensive line. ESPN’s Bill Barnwell believes Gettleman’s work is not done and they should bring in a free agent to bolster the pass rush. Hopefully, Big Blue’s front office is keeping an eye on other team rosters as training camps get underway in July. But if they’re soliciting advice, the two linebackers the Giants should consider are Nick Perry and Sam Acho.

Nick Perry

Matt Lombardo of wrote, “At age 28, Nick Perry can still be a productive member of a pass rush rotation. Despite being plagued by injuries the past three seasons, Perry has 19.5 sacks, 114 total tackles, 20 tackles for loss and 33 quarterback hits over that span. Perry, chosen by the Packers in the first round of the 2012 NFL Draft, is exactly the type of under the radar veteran the Giants should be targeting.”

Sam Acho

Sam Acho is a strong veteran presence who suffered a season-ending torn pectoral muscle in October 2018. He would theoretically sign for the veteran’s minimum but would add depth, experience, and leadership to the Giants young locker room.

Main Photo

Embed from Getty Images

(Comments, if enabled, are below this video.)

Warning: Use of undefined constant TDC_PATH_LEGACY - assumed 'TDC_PATH_LEGACY' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /data/www/ on line 107

2 Responses You are logged in as Test

  1. Sure seems that way (i.e., no pass rush for 2019).

    What if we’re all wrong and Edge Rushers Loenzo Carter and Markus Golden along with Oshane Ximines?

    And they surprise everyone and exhibit some pressure counter to what PFF believes????
    Stranger things have happened in stranger NFL contexts!
    E.g., how many Super Bowls has New England won vs. the Giants. (Remember 18-1?).

    1. Giants fan would be thrilled if their young pass rushers pan out. But the chances are slim. 4 out of the top 5 pass rushers in the league were first-round picks with highly touted college careers. Von Miller (2nd overall), Aaron Donald (first round), Khalil Mack (fifth overall), and JJ Watt (first round) were studs. If you don’t have a superstar pass rusher on your roster, you need LB/DE depth. Giants have neither.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.